Best Toaster Ovens of 2026: Tested Across 8 Brands
Over the past six weeks I’ve had eight toaster ovens cycling through my Portland counter — some bought, a couple borrowed from friends, one returned after four days when the door hinge started sagging. A toaster oven has to earn permanent counter space, which means it needs to do more than toast: bake, broil, and increasingly, air fry, all without turning into a space heater in a small kitchen. I ran the same test batch through every unit — a tray of tater tots for even crisping, a batch of cookies for hot-spot mapping, a small chicken where the interior was big enough to fit one — and five ovens earned a permanent spot on my counter. Here’s what I’d actually buy.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through them, I may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
In Brief:
The toaster oven I’d recommend to most people is the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro — it’s the most expensive pick here, but the even heating and true air fry basket justify the price if you’re replacing a countertop air fryer at the same time. If you just want excellent toast and baking and don’t care about air frying, the Breville Smart Oven Countertop Convection is the simpler, cheaper sibling with the same even-heat element. The Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven is the best value air-fry combo, the Ninja Flip-Up Toaster Oven is the pick for tight counters, and the Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 is the no-frills option if all you want is reliable toast and basic baking without digital controls.
How I Tested These
I ran every oven through the same three-part test so the comparisons would actually mean something. First, a tray of frozen tater tots straight from the freezer, checked at the same time mark across all eight units, to see which ones crisped evenly versus which left a soggy patch in the back corner. Second, a batch of drop cookies baked on the center rack, which exposes hot spots faster than almost anything else — an oven that runs hot on one side will brown one edge of the tray darker than the other. Third, for any unit with air fry, a batch of frozen fries measured against the same fries cooked in my daily-use dedicated air fryer, to see whether the toaster oven’s air fry setting was a genuine substitute or a marketing checkbox. I also timed preheat from cold start to 400°F on every unit, since that’s the difference between “quick weeknight dinner” and “wait fifteen minutes before you can even start.”
What to Look for in a Toaster Oven
The single biggest mistake I see people make is buying on price alone and then finding out the interior can’t fit a 9×13 pan, a whole small chicken, or a full sheet of cookies. Before I test anything, I check the stated interior capacity in quarts or cubic feet and then actually put a real pan in it — the numbers on the box don’t always match usable space once the heating elements and racks take up room. If you regularly cook for more than two people, size up; if you’re mostly reheating leftovers and making toast, a compact unit saves counter space you’ll actually miss.
The second question is what functions you actually need versus what sounds nice on a spec sheet. Toast, bake, and broil cover the basics. Convection adds a fan that speeds up cooking and browns more evenly — worth having. Air fry is the function everyone wants now, but it only matters if you’ll use it instead of buying a separate air fryer; if you already own one you love, you might not need it duplicated here. I also pay attention to wattage (1,800W units preheat noticeably faster than 1,200–1,500W ones) and whether controls are digital presets or manual dials — dials are more durable long-term but less precise for things like proofing dough.
Cleanup matters more than most buying guides admit, since a toaster oven that’s annoying to clean ends up neglected until crumbs start smoking on the heating element. I look for a slide-out or fold-down crumb tray, a non-stick interior coating, and racks and pans that fit in a standard sink rather than needing to be washed by hand in awkward pieces. Included accessories are worth checking too — an air fry basket, a rotisserie spit, or a dedicated pizza stone can save you from buying separate bakeware, but a unit that ships with only a single wire rack will need you to buy pans separately before you can use half its functions.
The 5 Toaster Ovens That Earned a Spot on My Counter
Best Overall: Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro
This is the unit I’d tell most people to just buy if budget allows. Breville’s Element iQ system runs six independent quartz heating elements and directs power to whichever ones a given function needs most, which is why toast comes out evenly browned edge to edge instead of pale in the middle. It packs 13 preset functions — air fry, slow cook, roast, broil, bake, cookies, pizza, toast, bagel, reheat, proof, dehydrate, and warm — into a stainless steel body large enough to fit a 9×13 pan or a small whole chicken. In my testing, the air fry basket produced tater tots as crisp as my dedicated air fryer, which is the whole point of buying one of these instead of two separate appliances. Preheat to 400°F took just under four minutes, the fastest of any unit I tested, and the interior light and large window made it easy to check on food without opening the door and losing heat. The included accessories — a wire rack, broiling/roasting pan, and air fry basket — meant I never had to buy separate bakeware to use any of its 13 functions.
Breville BOV900BSS Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro and Convection Oven — the most complete toaster oven I tested, with a true air fry basket that replaces a separate air fryer.
Con: At roughly $400, it’s the most expensive oven in this roundup by a wide margin, and its footprint is large enough that it needs real counter real estate, not a tight gap between other appliances.
Best for Toast & Baking (No Air Fry): Breville Smart Oven Countertop Convection
This is the Air Fryer Pro’s simpler sibling, and it’s the one I’d buy if air frying isn’t the point for you. It uses the same Element iQ heating system, so toast and baked goods come out just as evenly browned, but it drops the air fry basket and a few of the pricier extras in exchange for a friendlier price. In my side-by-side cookie test, the two Brevilles produced nearly identical results — same even color, same bake time — which tells me the air fry function on the pricier model is genuinely additive rather than a trade-off against baking performance. It’s a touch smaller than the Pro model too, which actually helped it slot into my counter layout better, and the crumb tray slides out from the front instead of requiring the whole unit to be tilted for cleaning.
Breville BOV800XL Smart Oven Countertop Convection — the same even-heat performance as the Pro model, without the air fry basket or the price tag.
Con: There’s no air fry function at all, so if crispy fries and wings without oil are the main reason you’re shopping, this isn’t the model — go with the Pro version or a dedicated air fryer instead.
Best Value Air Fry Combo: Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven
If the Breville Pro’s price makes you wince, this Cuisinart gets you most of the same functionality — 1,800 watts, 8-in-1 with air fry, convection, broil, and warm — for well under half the cost. It’s a 0.6 cubic foot interior, so it’s smaller than either Breville, but for two people it handled everything I threw at it: a full tray of frozen fries came out crisp in the air fry setting, and toast browned evenly across all four slots. It’s the one I’d point a reader to if “good enough at a fair price” matters more than “best possible result.” Preheat ran about a minute and a half slower than the Breville Pro, which I didn’t notice until I timed it with a stopwatch, and the included air fry basket and baking pan covered everything in my test batch without needing extra bakeware.
Cuisinart Air Fryer Toaster Oven, 1800W, 8-in-1 (TOA-70NAS) — most of the Breville Pro’s functionality at well under half the price.
Con: The 0.6 cubic foot interior is tight for a full 9×13 pan or anything larger than a small chicken — cooking for four or more, you’ll be running multiple batches.
Best for Small Kitchens: Ninja Flip-Up Toaster Oven
My kitchen has about fourteen inches of counter space that isn’t already claimed by something else, and this Ninja is the only oven in this list built specifically for that problem. When you’re done cooking, the whole unit flips up and locks flat against the wall, shrinking its counter footprint to almost nothing. It still packs 8-in-1 functionality at 1,800 watts, with a flip-up air fry basket, sheet pan, and wire rack included, and performance was on par with the Cuisinart in my toast and air fry tests — this isn’t a compromise oven, it’s a space-saving one. My only adjustment period was remembering to swing it back down before starting a new cook, since the flip mechanism locks firmly enough that it doesn’t budge on its own, which is reassuring once you trust it but takes a session or two to get used to.
Ninja Air Fryer Toaster Oven Combo, 8-in-1, Flip Up & Away (SP151) — the only oven here designed to disappear against the wall when you’re not using it.
Con: You need clear wall space directly above the unit for it to flip up, and the hinge mechanism takes a few tries to get comfortable with before it feels natural.
Best Budget Pick: Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Toaster Oven
Not everyone wants or needs air fry, convection, or a touchscreen, and at under $100 this Hamilton Beach is proof a toaster oven doesn’t need any of that to do its core job well. It’s a straightforward toast-and-bake unit with a shade selector, a 60-minute timer, and automatic shutoff — manual dials instead of digital presets, which means one less thing to break in a few years. In testing it browned toast evenly and baked a tray of cookies without hot spots, which is genuinely all most people need from a toaster oven. Preheat was the slowest of the five at around six minutes to 400°F, and there’s no interior light, so I found myself opening the door to check food more often than with the digital units — a minor habit change rather than a real downside.
Hamilton Beach 2-in-1 Countertop Toaster Oven and Long Slot Toaster (31156) — reliable toast and basic baking with manual dials, at the lowest price in this roundup.
Con: No air fry and no digital controls — if you want any of the convenience features on the other four ovens, this one won’t have them.
Where This Fits Into the Rest of Your Kitchen
A toaster oven rarely lives on its own — it’s usually competing with or complementing an air fryer, and sometimes standing in for a full-size oven entirely. If you’re deciding between the two appliance categories rather than within this list, my air fryer vs. convection oven breakdown covers when each one actually wins. If you’d rather keep air frying and toasting as two separate dedicated appliances instead of one combo unit, my best air fryers of 2026 guide has the models I still use after 200+ meals of testing. For the bigger picture of outfitting a kitchen’s countertop appliance lineup — including where a stand mixer fits into the budget — see my best stand mixers under $300 comparison and the full best small kitchen appliances of 2026 pillar guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a toaster oven the same as an air fryer?
Not quite. A toaster oven is a small countertop oven built primarily for toasting, baking, and broiling; some newer models add an air fry basket that circulates hot air the way a dedicated air fryer does. If a toaster oven advertises an air fry setting — like the Breville Pro, Cuisinart, or Ninja above — it can genuinely replace a separate air fryer. Models without that setting, like the base Breville and the Hamilton Beach here, cannot air fry no matter how you adjust the temperature.
What size toaster oven do I need?
For one or two people, a compact 0.5–0.6 cubic foot unit like the Cuisinart is usually plenty. For a family, or if you want to bake a 9×13 pan or fit a small whole chicken, size up to something in the Breville Smart Oven range — check the stated interior dimensions against your actual bakeware before buying, not just the marketing capacity number.
Are toaster ovens worth it over using a full-size oven?
For small batches, yes — a toaster oven preheats in a couple of minutes instead of ten or more, and it doesn’t heat up your whole kitchen to reheat a slice of pizza. I still use my full-size oven for large roasts, sheet-pan dinners for a crowd, or anything that needs multiple racks, but for everyday toast, small batches, and reheating, the toaster oven gets far more daily use in my kitchen.
Do toaster ovens use a lot of electricity?
Less than you’d think, and far less than running a full-size oven. Most of the units here draw around 1,800 watts at peak, but a toaster oven only runs at that peak briefly during preheat and then cycles on and off to maintain temperature — for a quick reheat or a single tray of cookies, it uses a fraction of the energy a full-size oven would for the same job, since it’s heating a much smaller space.
Can a toaster oven replace a full-size oven entirely?
For a single person or a couple, mostly yes — I’ve gone weeks using only the Breville Pro for baking, roasting, and reheating without missing my full-size oven. Where it falls short is volume: if you regularly cook for a crowd, need multiple racks going at once, or want to roast a full-size turkey, you’ll still want a conventional oven as backup.
The Bottom Line
After six weeks of rotating eight ovens through my counter, the honest answer is that the “best” one depends on which trade-off you’re willing to make. If you want one appliance to replace both your toaster oven and your air fryer, buy the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro and don’t look back. If air fry isn’t the point, the cheaper Breville Countertop Convection gives you the same even heat for less money. Tight on counter space or on a tighter budget? The Ninja flip-up and the Cuisinart both earned their spot for different reasons, and the Hamilton Beach proves you don’t need any of the extra functions if all you want is reliable toast. All five are still on rotation in my kitchen, which is the only test that really matters after the review is published.
